AI study guide · KJV · Grammatical‑historical
Job 35
Summary, themes and context for Job 35, read with grammatical-historical hermeneutics. The text is quoted before it is interpreted.
Job 35
Summary
Job 35 is the third of Elihu's four speeches, in which he answers two specific complaints he attributes to Job: that Job's righteousness profits him nothing more than God's, and that God ignores the cries of the oppressed. Elihu argues from God's transcendence that human sin and righteousness neither harm nor benefit God Himself (they affect fellow human beings), and that unanswered prayer often stems from proud, self-centered crying that fails to seek 'God my maker, who giveth songs in the night' (Job 35:10). He concludes that Job has spoken in vain and 'multiplieth words without knowledge' (Job 35:16).
- Elihu confronts Job's claim that godliness gives no advantage over sinning, asking whether 'My righteousness is more than God's' is a right thing to say (Job 35:2-3).
- Elihu directs Job to look up at the heavens and clouds, far above him, to grasp how far above human reach God is (Job 35:4-5).
- From God's height Elihu reasons that human sin and righteousness touch fellow men, not the self-sufficient God (Job 35:6-8).
- Elihu addresses why the oppressed cry yet go unanswered: they wail under affliction but none asks for their Maker who gives songs in the night and wisdom above the beasts (Job 35:9-11).
- He explains the silence: God will not hear empty, proud crying — 'vanity' the Almighty will not regard (Job 35:12-13).
- Elihu turns to exhort: though Job says he cannot see God, judgment is before Him, so Job should trust and wait (Job 35:14-15).
- Elihu's verdict: Job opens his mouth in vain and multiplies words without knowledge (Job 35:16).
- The charge in Job 35:2, 'My righteousness is more than God's,' is Elihu's pointed restatement of Job's frustration that his integrity has gone unrewarded.
- Job 35:3 echoes Job's earlier sentiment (compare Job 34:9) that there is no profit in being cleansed from sin.
- 'Songs in the night' (Job 35:10) is a striking image: God supplies joy and comfort precisely in the darkest seasons.
- Job 35:11 contrasts humans, taught and made wiser than 'the beasts of the earth' and 'the fowls of heaven,' underscoring the dignity and accountability of human beings who ought to seek their Maker.
- Job 35:13 states a principle of unanswered prayer: God 'will not hear vanity' — empty crying not directed to Him in trust.
- Job 35:14 holds together apparent absence ('thou shalt not see him') with the call to trust because 'judgment is before him.'
- The chapter ends (Job 35:16) anticipating language the LORD Himself will use in Job 38:2 about words 'without knowledge.'
Job 35 wrestles with two perennial questions: Does it pay to serve God, and why does God seem silent when the afflicted cry? Elihu's answer reframes both around God's transcendence and self-sufficiency — God is not enriched by our obedience nor injured by our sin (so our righteousness is for the good of others and ourselves), and unanswered prayer can expose hearts that complain without truly seeking God. The chapter presses the reader toward humble trust rather than accusation, while leaving the deeper resolution of Job's suffering to the LORD's later speeches.
God is too high to be bribed by our goodness or harmed by our sin; the call in suffering is not to charge God with injustice but to seek 'God my maker, who giveth songs in the night' and to trust His judgment even when He seems unseen.
Themes
The chapter moves from rebuke (a restated accusation against Job, Job 35:2-3), to argument from God's transcendence (Job 35:4-8), to a theodicy of unanswered prayer (Job 35:9-13), to exhortation and verdict (Job 35:14-16). It is a disputation speech: Elihu quotes his opponent, refutes by appeal to creation and the character of God, and renders judgment.
Quoted-accusation pattern
Elihu opens by citing Job's own words ('thou saidst...') twice, setting up a point-by-point rebuttal characteristic of legal-style disputation.
Appeal to the heavens
Elihu commands Job to 'Look unto the heavens' and behold the clouds 'higher than thou,' using vertical imagery to argue God's distance from human merit or demerit.
Rhetorical question chain
A series of 'what doest thou... what givest thou... what receiveth he' questions drives home that God gains and loses nothing from human conduct.
God's transcendence and self-sufficiency
Elihu insists that the infinitely high God is neither benefited by human righteousness nor damaged by human sin: 'If thou sinnest, what doest thou against him?... If thou be righteous, what givest thou him?' (Job 35:6-7). God's blessedness does not depend on His creatures.
Human conduct affects humans
Because God is beyond gain or loss, the real arena of sin and righteousness is human community: 'Thy wickedness may hurt a man as thou art; and thy righteousness may profit the son of man' (Job 35:8). Sin wrongs the sinner and his neighbors rather than diminishing God.
God gives songs in the night
Elihu names God as 'my maker, who giveth songs in the night' (Job 35:10), teaching that God provides comfort and joy within affliction and endows people with wisdom above the animals (Job 35:11) — a gift the oppressed fail to seek.
Why some cries go unanswered
Elihu distinguishes mere wailing under pain from prayer that seeks God: 'they cry, but none giveth answer, because of the pride of evil men' (Job 35:12), for 'God will not hear vanity' (Job 35:13). Matthew Henry observes that when we 'pore upon our afflictions, and neglect the consolations of God,' it is just for God to reject such prayers.
- God 'will not hear vanity' — empty, proud crying that does not truly seek Him goes unanswered (Job 35:12-13).
- To claim 'My righteousness is more than God's' is to open one's mouth in vain and multiply 'words without knowledge' (Job 35:2, Job 35:16).
Context
- Job is set in the patriarchal era, with wealth measured in livestock and the patriarch acting as priest for his household; the dialogue reflects an ancient wisdom dispute over suffering and divine justice rather than later Israelite institutions.
- Elihu is introduced in Job 32 as a younger man who waited to speak until the three friends fell silent; Job 35 belongs to the second cycle of his four-part discourse (Job 32-37) that bridges the friends' speeches and the LORD's answer from the whirlwind.
- Elihu's argument that God is unprofited by human merit overlaps with Eliphaz's earlier claims (Job 22:2-3), placing Elihu partly within the friends' tradition while he also presses new points.
- 'Songs in the night' (Job 35:10) draws on the ancient practice of song as expression of deliverance and worship, evoking joy granted in seasons of darkness and distress.
- The contrast with 'the beasts of the earth' and 'the fowls of heaven' (Job 35:11) reflects a wisdom-tradition ranking that sees humanity as uniquely taught and accountable, set above the animal world.
- 'The arm of the mighty' (Job 35:9) pictures the oppressive power of the strong over the weak, a recurring concern of ancient Near Eastern justice and Hebrew wisdom.
- Elihu uses the disputation device of quoting his opponent ('thou saidst,' Job 35:2-3) before rebutting, a standard move in the poetic dialogues of Job.
- The vertical imagery — heavens, clouds 'higher than thou' (Job 35:5) — functions as a visual argument: physical height illustrates God's metaphysical transcendence above human deeds.
- The cascade of rhetorical questions in Job 35:6-7 is parallelistic, pairing sin/transgression with righteousness to show symmetry: neither moves God.
- The speech is bracketed by the motif of futile speech, opening with Job's faulty sayings and closing with the verdict of 'words without knowledge' (Job 35:16).
- Job 35:3 alludes to Job's prior complaint, restated by Elihu in Job 34:9, that there is no profit in pleasing God.
- Job 35:7 stands parallel to Eliphaz's argument in Job 22:2 that man cannot be profitable to God, and is taken up by Paul in Rom 11:35, 'who hath first given to him?'
- Job 35:9 references Job's earlier charge in Job 24:12 that God ignores the groans of the oppressed.
- Job 35:13 parallels Job's own earlier admission in Job 27:9 that God will not hear the cry of the hypocrite.
- Job 35:16 anticipates the LORD's opening rebuke in Job 38:2 concerning one who 'darkeneth counsel by words without knowledge,' and echoes the prior conclusion of Job 34:35-37.
- Act 16:25 records Paul and Silas singing hymns at midnight in prison — a historical embodiment of God giving 'songs in the night' (Job 35:10).
- Psa 42:8 voices the same confidence: 'in the night his song shall be with me,' resonating with Job 35:10.
- Luk 17:10 echoes Job 35:7 — even faithful servants remain 'unprofitable,' giving God nothing He needs.
- Pro 8:36 parallels Job 35:6-8: the one who sins against wisdom 'wrongeth his own soul,' confirming that sin harms the sinner, not God.
- Jer 7:19 declares that those who provoke do not harm God but themselves, paralleling Job 35:6.
- Isa 51:13 rebukes the oppressed for forgetting 'the LORD thy maker,' matching Elihu's complaint in Job 35:10 that none says 'Where is God my maker?'
- v2 'right' renders צֶדֶק (tsedeq, H6664), natural/moral/legal rightness; v2 'just' renders מִשְׁפָּט (mishpat, H4941), a judicial verdict or justice — Elihu questions whether Job's claim is a sound legal-moral judgment.
- v3 'advantage' translates סָכַן (sakan, H5532, to be serviceable/profitable) and 'profit' translates יַעַל (ya'al, H3276, to be of use or benefit), sharpening Job's reported cost-benefit objection to godliness.
- v6-7 pair the verbs חָטָא (chata, H2398, to miss/sin) and צָדַק (tsadaq, H6663, to be righteous), framing the symmetry that neither sin nor righteousness reaches God.
- v10 'maker' is from עָשָׂה (asah, H6213, to make); the phrase 'songs in the night' joins this Creator-title to the gift of joy in darkness, a hallmark image of the chapter.
- v13 'vanity' / empty crying is what God 'will not hear'; the term אֵל (El, H410, the Mighty One / Almighty) in v2 and v13 emphasizes the divine majesty that grounds Elihu's argument.
- v16 'in vain' (empty breath) and the verb רָבַב (rabab, H7231, to multiply) underlie 'multiplieth words,' the climactic charge against Job's speech.
- Elihu is restating, perhaps sharpening, Job's words: Job never says verbatim 'My righteousness is more than God's,' so Job 35:2 is Elihu's interpretive paraphrase of Job's protests — readers should weigh whether it fairly represents Job.
- The distinction in Job 35:12-13 is between crying out of pain (which the proud do) and praying in trust to one's Maker (Job 35:10); Elihu attributes silence not to God's injustice but to the character of the crying.
- Job 35:8 quietly relocates the moral stakes of human conduct: sin and righteousness matter intensely — but horizontally, toward fellow humans — not as gain or loss to God.
- Elihu's verdict in Job 35:16 will be partly vindicated by God's own words in Job 38:2, yet the LORD also rebukes the friends (Job 42:7) — so Elihu's standing in the book remains a deliberate open question.
- Job 35:15 is notoriously difficult in Hebrew; the KJV's 'because it is not so, he hath visited in his anger; yet he knoweth it not in great extremity' is one of several renderings, and the precise sense of who 'knoweth it not' is debated.
- The book never explicitly evaluates Elihu — he is neither rebuked with the three friends in Job 42:7 nor commended — so the degree to which his arguments in Job 35 carry the book's own verdict is left to the reader.
- Whether 'My righteousness is more than God's' (Job 35:2) is an accurate summary of Job's position or an overstatement by Elihu is an interpretive judgment the text invites but does not settle.
- How does the LORD's rebuke in Job 38:2 about 'words without knowledge' relate to Elihu's charge in Job 35:16?
- What does the Bible mean by God giving 'songs in the night,' and how do Acts 16:25 and Psalm 42:8 illustrate it?
- Compare Elihu's argument in Job 35:7 with Paul's question in Romans 11:35 — can anyone put God in their debt?
- Why does the book of Job leave Elihu unjudged while explicitly rebuking the three friends in Job 42:7?
To ask any of these as follow-up questions, install SwordBible on iOS — the study workspace there grounds every follow-up in the full prior study automatically.
Common questions
What is Job 35 about?
Job 35 is the third of Elihu's four speeches, in which he answers two specific complaints he attributes to Job: that Job's righteousness profits him nothing more than God's, and that God ignores the cries of the oppressed. Elihu argues from God's transcendence that human sin and righteousness neither harm nor benefit God Himself (they affect fellow human beings), and that unanswered prayer often stems from proud, self-centered crying that fails to seek 'God my maker, who giveth songs in the night' (Job 35:10). He concludes that Job has spoken in vain and 'multiplieth words without knowledge' (Job 35:16).
What are the main themes of Job 35?
The main themes in this guide are God's transcendence and self-sufficiency, Human conduct affects humans, God gives songs in the night, Why some cries go unanswered, and Trust amid apparent absence.
Is this study guide written by AI?
Yes. The summary, themes and context are written by AI from the Bible text and can contain mistakes. Check them against the passage and the public-domain commentaries linked on this page.